Flush Mount vs Recessed Lighting: Which to Buy

Flush mount vs recessed lighting is settled by what is already in your ceiling, so start by counting the junction boxes. One box with no attic access means buy the flush mount: it hardwires to the box that is already there and cuts no holes, while recessed needs an aperture for every can, cable fished between joists at 16 in (41 cm) on centre, and an electrician's time for each hole. The 8.7 in (22 cm) travertine fixture Houseland sells sits 1.6 in (4 cm) below the plaster and draws 28W on that one circuit.

Flush mount vs recessed lighting: which one fits your ceiling?

The ceiling with a junction box already in it. Recessed downlights are a building job: every can is a hole, a cable run and a fixing, and what sits above the plasterboard only shows itself once you cut. A flush mount is a fixture swap, and the ceiling looks the same again the day you take it down. Count the junction boxes in your ceiling before you look at a single photo, because one box with no access above it decides this for you.

One fixture at $124.99 is a number you can hold in your head before anybody opens a ceiling. Recessed downlights vs ceiling lamp cost runs the other way, priced per hole: a housing, a termination and a hole saw pass every time, so the total only exists once you have settled on a count. Ask an electrician for a price per can rather than a price for the job, then multiply by your own count, which is the same arithmetic that shows what the money buys in a cheap versus an expensive flush mount.

Do recessed lights need attic access?

No, but the cable does. Remodel cans are built for finished ceilings and clip up into the plasterboard on spring arms, so the housing itself is rarely the obstacle. The cable is: it has to reach every hole from the switch, and with nothing but plaster above you it means fishing through bays framed at 16 in (41 cm) on centre. Attic access changes the price more than it changes the shopping list, because with a boarded loft the electrician works from above, and without one every pull happens through a 4 in (10 cm) hole on the end of a rod.

Measure two things before you commit. Depth first: put a torch into an existing hole and check there is clear space above the plasterboard for the housing, since a joist, a duct or a firebreak in the wrong bay moves that can 16 in (41 cm) sideways whether the room wanted light there or not. Then the aperture, because 4 in (10 cm) and 6 in (15 cm) are the common sizes and the one you pick sets both the count and how the ceiling reads from the door. If there is insulation above the ceiling, the housing has to be rated for contact with it, and that is printed on the can rather than judged by eye.

How do I replace recessed lights with a flush mount ceiling light?

You cover one hole and patch the rest. People who have lived under can lights for years ask whether they can replace recessed lights with a flush mount, and the answer is yes, as long as one of those holes can carry a junction box.

1. Turn the power off at the breaker and test at the terminals before you touch a wire.
2. Stand in the room at night with the cans lit and pick the hole that keeps the light, usually the one over the walked path rather than the one by the door.
3. Measure that hole, because a 6 in (15 cm) aperture sits comfortably under an 8.7 in (22 cm) body while anything wider than the fixture means patching and painting instead of covering.
4. Have a qualified electrician fit a ceiling box at that hole, connect the supply and confirm the box will carry the fixture, which matters here because this is a hardwired surface mount fixture and the box does the holding.
5. Cap the redundant cables and patch the other holes with plasterboard offcuts and filler, or the ceiling keeps a row of blanking plates as a record of the old layout.
6. Mount the base, fit the 8.7 in (22 cm) body, restore power, and look at the 3000K warm white against your wall colour before the ladder goes away.

Which is brighter, a flush mount or a recessed downlight?

Neither, because brightness is a question of fixture and count rather than type. This one draws 28W in total from a single position on the ceiling. A run of downlights draws whatever each can draws multiplied by how many you fit, so the comparison is 28W in one place against a per can figure times your own number.

Shape matters more than total draw in a corridor. The flush mount throws a side halo as well as light down through a 5.9 in (15 cm) lower diffuser, so the walls and the ceiling get some and the room reads even. A downlight sends a cone at the floor, which is why hallway cans leave scallops down the wall and a dark strip along the ceiling. Ask for lumens rather than watts on anything you buy: this listing publishes 28W and 3000K rather than a lumen figure, so a specific light level is a number to chase on the spec sheet.

Colour temperature is the detail people forget on a run of cans, and one cooler can in the middle of a warm row is visible from the door.

What should I fit in a rented flat with a low ceiling?

A flush mount, and nothing that needs a hole saw. Flush mount or recessed lights for low ceilings is the easiest version of this question, because a fixture 1.6 in (4 cm) high takes very little off the headroom of a 96 in (244 cm) ceiling, and a rented ceiling should leave with the same number of holes it had when you moved in. In a rental, recessed versus surface mount ceiling light is a deposit decision more than a lighting one.

Measure your own ceiling instead of assuming 96 in (244 cm), because older flats, converted lofts and basements run lower and that number changes what you can hang. Then measure the walked path, since an 8.7 in (22 cm) round suits a corridor or an entry while a wider room wants a bigger diameter or a second fixture, which is how the sizing question usually gets settled. If your ceiling comes in under the standard height, the low ceiling shortlist is a better starting point than a photo you liked.

From the shop

Flush Mount Ceiling Light, Travertine Wood Hallway Fixture, 8.7 In

8.7 in (22 cm) across and 1.6 in (4 cm) high, drawing 28W in total on 85V to 265V, hardwired to one ceiling box. Natural Wood or Walnut, both warm white.

See the flush mount ceiling light

Where should I buy wall lights and sconces?

Houseland is worth buying this particular job from, a hardwired fixture on one box you already have, and the case is three facts rather than three adjectives. The numbers are published before you order: 8.7 in (22 cm) diameter, 1.6 in (4 cm) height and a 5.9 in (15 cm) lower diffuser, so you can hold a tape to your ceiling and know whether it covers the hole you have. It runs on 85V to 265V and draws 28W, and the product page says to turn the power off at the breaker and have a qualified electrician mount the base, connect the wiring and confirm the ceiling box can support the fixture. The materials are named rather than flattered: yellow travertine natural stone, an iron body and a wood or walnut centre, in Natural Wood or Walnut, both at 8.7 in (22 cm) and both warm white. The listing also says stone pores and tone variation are part of the material appearance, which is the sentence that prevents a return.

It is the wrong fixture for an open plan living room, because one 8.7 in (22 cm) unit drawing 28W lights a hallway, an entry, a bedroom or a small lounge. It is wrong for a shower or an exposed outdoor spot, because the listing does not document a wet rating and dry covered transitions are the limit. It is wrong for a renter who cannot have an electrician near the wiring, because it is hardwired and there is no plug. And it is wrong if you want the ceiling to look empty, since this sits 1.6 in (4 cm) proud with a stone ring on show, which is what cans are for.

What would I buy first?

The flush mount, on the box that is already there. It is the cheaper alternative to recessed lighting in the literal sense: one fixture at $124.99 against a housing, a hole and a termination repeated for every can, and it is the only one of the two you can undo. A row of holes in a corridor gives you a ceiling that reads like a serviced office, and plasterboard does not go back. One 8.7 in (22 cm) fixture, 1.6 in (4 cm) deep, 28W, wired to what you already own, comes down again with a screwdriver.

Shop wall lamps from Houseland

-20%Globe Wall Sconce with Switch, Pull Chain Glass Wall Lamp, 4 Shapes 4 Colorsfrom $104.46$130.58-20%Bear Nursery Wall Sconce, Adjustable Iron Wall Lamp with Wood Base, 8 Colorsfrom $97.89$122.36-20%Macaron Bedside Wall Sconce, Adjustable Wood Base Wall Lamp, 3 Shapes 13 Colorsfrom $86.47$108.09-20%Vanity Sconce with Exposed Globe Bulb, Adjustable Iron Wall Lamp, 5 Colorsfrom $72.22$90.28-20%Fluted Resin Hallway Sconce, Up Down Wall Light in 4 Colors, Two G9 Bulbsfrom $83.79$104.74Wood Flush Mount Ceiling Light, Walnut or Natural, Slim or Tall LED Fixturefrom $99.95

See all wall lamps →