How to Make Crab Cakes That Hold Together With Little Filler

You paid for a pound of lump crab, and the last batch came out as either bread patties with a rumor of crab or a pile of loose crab in hot butter. Here is how to make crab cakes that hold together with almost no filler: bind 1 lb of crab with just 2 tablespoons of mayonnaise and 1 egg, roll it into a foil log, freeze it until stiff, slice it into disks, and bread only one side.

That's Serious Eats' Food Lab method, and the cold, not the crumbs, does the holding. Houseland's uncoated titanium frying pan comes in 10.2 in (26 cm) and 11 in (28 cm) cooking diameters with a tempered glass lid, which suits the stovetop finish from America's Test Kitchen further down.

Why do crab cakes fall apart or taste like bread?

Because crab meat doesn't bind to itself. Serious Eats found you can press and knead picked crab all you like and only turn it into paste that still won't stick; it needs raw, uncooked protein such as egg to glue it.

• Egg and crab alone are too loose: the cakes sag and spread like a deflated jellyfish, in Serious Eats' words.
• The usual fix is starch: flour, bread crumbs, saltines or oyster crackers. Serious Eats notes that the more binder you add, the easier the cakes are to handle and the worse the texture.
• Batter-style binders: eggs, flour and mayo make a cake that is vaguely pancake- or fritter-like.
• Warm mixture in the pan: Serious Eats' frozen, breaded cakes without their foil fell apart as they slowly thawed in the skillet.
• Overmixing: both ATK recipes fold the crab in gently so the big lumps survive; broken lumps make a pasty cake.

Your crab isn't failing you. It just needs a cold, firm start.

How to make crab cakes that hold together, step by step?

Mix gently, shape a log, freeze twice, slice, and bread one face. This is how to make crab cakes the Serious Eats way, for 4 to 6 servings:

1. Fold the mixture: 1 lb (455 g) fresh lump or jumbo lump crab, 2 tablespoons mayonnaise, 2 tablespoons chopped herbs if you like, and 1 egg. Fold with a flexible spatula without breaking up the lumps.
2. Roll a log: lay a 12 x 18 in sheet of foil on the counter, form the crab into a rough log about 6 in wide, 4 in from the bottom edge, and roll it up. Twist the ends into a tight roll 3 to 4 in across.
3. First freeze: 20 to 25 minutes, until lightly stiff.
4. Slice: cut off a twisted end, then slice the log into 4 or 6 disks about 1 1/2 in thick, foil still on. Shape the scraps from the ends into one free-form cake.
5. Second freeze: another 20 to 25 minutes, until the disks are fairly stiff.
6. Bread one side: dip one cut face in the second beaten egg, then in 1 1/2 cups panko, and press gently.
7. Fry breaded side down in 3 tablespoons each of oil and butter once the foaming subsides, 3 minutes, then peel off the foil and cook about 2 minutes more.

Serious Eats borrowed the foil-log trick from a chef's burger method: the frozen log slices into disks that each keep a perfectly fitted foil collar. Total freezing time works out to 20 to 25 + 20 to 25 = 40 to 50 minutes.

Tip: slice with a sharp chef's knife in one smooth stroke rather than sawing, so the foil collar stays in place.

The foil is the filler. And you peel it off.

Pan size matters at the frying step: four disks up to 4 in across, set in a 2-by-2 block, need a circle about 4 × (1 + 1.41) = 9.6 in wide. Recommended for this use case: a cook making four Serious Eats disks or four ATK Maryland cakes should pick the 11 in (28 cm) size, which leaves 11 − 9.6 = 1.4 in of room around that block for two spatulas, against 0.6 in in the 10.2 in size. The trade-off is that bare titanium is not nonstick, and both recipes were written for nonstick or cast iron, so preheat on medium, let the fat foam and settle, and don't nudge the cakes until the crust releases. The listing names wood or silicone utensils to keep the finish looking new; see whether metal utensils are fine on an uncoated titanium pan and how much oil an uncoated frying pan actually needs. The rest of the range is in the kitchen and home collection.

From the shop

Titanium Frying Pan, Uncoated, Induction Safe, with Tempered Glass Lid

Best for pan-frying four crab cakes in butter and oil with a lid on; uncoated titanium cooking surface, 10.2 in (26 cm) or 11 in (28 cm) cooking diameter, tempered glass lid included; bare metal needs a proper preheat and a little fat, so let the crust release before you flip.

View the uncoated titanium pan — 2 sizes & current price

Mayo and egg vs bread crumbs vs shrimp: which binder holds best?

All three tested binders hold if the cakes are cold before they hit the pan; they differ in how much of the cake isn't crab. Here's how they compare for 1 lb of crab:

The ATK Maryland cakes check out: 8 oz jumbo lump plus 8 oz backfin or claw is 16 oz of crab, and 4 × 5 3/4 = 23 oz of mixture, so the binder and seasoning add about 23 − 16 = 7 oz. ATK's Best Crab Cakes skip crumbs inside entirely and let a shrimp mousse hold the lumps.

Pick by your crab. Jumbo lump deserves the Food Lab method; a mixed tub is happy in the Maryland cakes.

Does chilling or freezing crab cakes really help?

Yes, and it's the single step that matters most. Serious Eats took the idea from a restaurant trick for cod croquettes: make a barely bound filling, partly freeze it, then bread and fry it.

• Frozen, no foil: Serious Eats' cakes fell apart as they thawed, leaving loose crab and a disk of fried crumbs.
• Frozen, foil left on: the cakes held until they had cooked long enough to hold themselves, and then the foil came off.
• Chilled, not frozen: ATK's Maryland-style balls rest at least 1 hour and up to 24 hours; its Best Crab Cakes rest 30 minutes before breading.
• Handling: Serious Eats lifts each disk by the foil-lined edges, never by the crab.

Cold binder is firm binder. Warm crab cakes are just crab salad with ambitions.

How do you fry crab cakes without them breaking?

Medium heat, butter and oil, and no fiddling until the first side has set. Both ATK and Serious Eats wait until the butter's foaming subsides before the cakes go in.

• Don't move them early: ATK's Best Crab Cakes cook 3 to 4 minutes untouched, then flip with 2 spatulas.
• Use the lid: ATK's Maryland-style cakes cook covered about 5 minutes, then uncovered about 5 minutes after the flip, then rest off the heat, covered, about 3 minutes to heat through.
• Or skip the flip: Serious Eats bastes the tops with the browned butter and broils about 5 minutes, because flipping its fragile cakes proved tough even with a gentle metal fish spatula.
• Check the center: Serious Eats cooks to 145 to 160 °F inside; the FDA says most seafood should reach 145 °F.

Four Serious Eats disks, each 3 to 4 in across, sit in a 2-by-2 block that needs a circle of 3 × (1 + 1.41) = about 7.2 in to 4 × (1 + 1.41) = about 9.6 in.

Houseland lists the Titanium Frying Pan with an uncoated, hammered titanium cooking surface and a tempered glass lid sized to the pan, for induction, gas, electric and ceramic cooktops. Its FAQ says release comes from a proper preheat and a little fat, which matches the butter-and-oil start both recipes use. The listing is written for the cooktop, so this article keeps it there: use ATK's covered, stovetop finish, or slide Serious Eats' cakes onto a rimmed baking sheet for the broiler.

A crab cake that sticks was moved too soon. Give it the full minutes.

Can you shape crab cakes ahead, and how long do they keep?

Yes, before cooking, not after. ATK's Maryland-style mixture can be shaped and refrigerated up to 24 hours, and Serious Eats' disks are ready to bread straight from the freezer.

• Raw crab meat at home: the FDA says seafood you'll use within 2 days should be kept at 40 °F or below; otherwise wrap it tightly and freeze it.
• Shaped cakes: ATK covers the balls with plastic wrap and chills them at least 1 hour, up to 24 hours.
• Cooked cakes on the table: the FDA says never leave cooked seafood out more than 2 hours, or more than 1 hour above 90 °F.
• Packaged crab that smells off: ATK soaks it in milk in the fridge for at least 20 minutes, then drains it well; fresh-smelling crab just gets blotted dry.

That makes crab cakes a good Saturday plan: shape them in the morning, fry them at dinner. For another pan-fried patty that needs a hard crust, see how to make a smash burger in a frying pan at home.

Tip: set up the egg and panko bowls before the disks come out of the freezer, so they stay cold while you bread them.

Make them early. Cook them late. Eat them fast.

Shop kitchen & home from Houseland

-17%Stainless Steel Cutting Board, 304 Food Grade, Double Sided with Juice Groovefrom $49.99$59.99-25%Stainless Steel Finger Hand Protector, Knife Guardfrom $29.99$39.99-14%Kitchen Knife Sharpener, 3-Stage and 4-Stage Manual Pull-Throughfrom $29.99$34.99-20%Stainless Steel Bench Scraper and Dough Cutterfrom $29.99$37.49-22%Water-Seal Butter Crock with Lid, Reactive Glaze Ceramic Keeperfrom $69.99$89.99-50%Salt Cellar With Spoon, Ceramic Seasoning Jar With Bamboo Lidfrom $39.99$79.99

See all kitchen & home →