Is Drilling Nine Holes Worth It on a One-Year Lease?

Drilling nine holes is worth it if the shelves do a daily job for the whole lease year, and it is a poor trade if they are a weekend idea you will resent packing. Nine fixings is the exposure you are pricing: where a landlord treats them as damage, the usual flat charge runs $5 to $25 a hole, so nine of them is a $45 to $225 line on the move-out statement.

That ceiling is also the least interesting number in the decision. Two things move it much further than the count does: whether the holes sit in one crowded patch, and what your state makes the landlord document before it touches your deposit.

Is drilling nine holes worth it if your lease ends in a year?

Price it per month, then look at how often you use the wall. Nine holes at the usual $5 to $25 flat fee is $45 to $225, which is under $19 a month across a 12-month tenancy, and that is the ceiling rather than the expectation. Most tenants fill their own holes and the line never appears on the statement at all.

Use is the honest test. A run above a desk that holds the things you reach for daily pays back nine fixings inside a month. A cluster you walk past twice a day and never touch is the one to shrink before the drill comes out, because you are paying the same removal cost for decoration you stopped noticing in week three.

Then shrink the count itself rather than the ambition. Houseland lists the mount type on every module as a keyhole hanger and the contents of the small set as three hexagons plus two ledges, so dropping from a nine-module wall to a five-module one cuts the fixing points in the same proportion. Count the keyhole slots on the back of the piece in front of you and multiply by the number of modules. That number, not the price, is what you are committing to.

What can a landlord actually charge you per hole?

A reasonable repair cost, not a penalty. iPropertyManagement's write-up of deposit charges puts the typical figure at $5 to $25 per hole depending on size, and says the alternative is the actual cost of materials and labour, which the landlord can be asked to evidence with quotes.

The same page draws the line that decides a shelf wall. Small nail holes from hanging pictures and posters are normal wear and tear and cannot come out of the deposit. Four things get reclassified as damage: large holes from drilling, numerous holes in the same area, oversized nail holes, and holes that crack or damage the paint around them.

Three of those four describe a badly planned shelf wall, so nine holes spread over 6 ft of wall reads very differently from nine crowded into a 2 ft square. Spacing is free at the drilling stage and expensive afterwards.

Hole width is yours to choose too. A screw driven into a stud leaves a hole roughly the width of the screw; a plastic plug sized for that screw leaves a wider one; a toggle leaves the widest of the three. Our notes on anchors versus studs and on matching the bit to the anchor both come down to the same thing at move-out: the smallest hole your load actually needs.

Drilling vs adhesive strips: which costs less over one year?

Drilling costs more to undo and much less to worry about, while adhesive costs nothing to undo until the morning it takes the paint with it.

Read the number printed on the adhesive pack rather than a number from a review, because the rating is written for a flat item hung against the wall, not for a shelf with a pot standing on it. Test one strip low on the wall, behind furniture, and pull it a week later to see how your paint behaves before you trust the whole layout to it. Paint that comes away with the strip is a repaint, and a repaint is a bigger deduction than nine filled holes.

How do you cut the hole count before you buy?

Decide the layout first and let it pick the set, instead of buying the set and improvising the layout.

1. Count fixing points, not pieces. Read the mount type on the product page, then count the slots on one module and multiply. A set advertised by piece count tells you nothing until you do that.
2. Tape the shapes up and live with them for a week. Paper templates and low-tack tape cost nothing, and our walkthrough on testing a layout before you drill shows how far the arrangement usually moves in seven days.
3. Let one long ledge replace three small pieces. A single 27.6 in ledge covers the span that three separate hexagons would, on a fraction of the fixings, and it holds a row of frames the hexagons cannot.
4. Put the heavy modules on studs and the light ones anywhere. Stud fixings leave the narrowest holes, so spend them on whatever carries the most weight.
5. Keep the plugs, the screws and the offcut of paint. Bag them with the instructions on day one; the repair is an evening only if you are not shopping for parts on your last night in the flat.

The Houseland five-piece set is the one I would buy for a twelve-month tenancy: three hexagons at 13.8, 11.8 and 9.8 in wide, a 19.7 in ledge and a 27.6 in ledge, every module 3.5 in (9 cm) deep and rated up to 11 lb (5 kg) per piece. Same wall, five fixing runs to fill instead of nine.

From the shop

5-Piece Pine Ledge Wall Shelf Set

Three hexagons 13.8 / 11.8 / 9.8 in wide with a 19.7 in and a 27.6 in ledge, all 3.5 in (9 cm) deep in natural pine with a clear matte lacquer. Wall mounted on keyhole hangers, rated up to 11 lb (5 kg) per piece.

View the 5-piece pine ledge shelf set — dimensions & current price

What does your state make the landlord prove?

Paperwork, on a clock, and that is your real protection. California Civil Code 1950.5 gives a landlord 21 calendar days after you vacate to send an itemised statement, allows deductions only for repairs to damage exclusive of ordinary wear and tear, and stops there unless the paperwork follows: where repairs and cleaning together come to more than $125, the tenant is entitled to the receipts, invoices or a written breakdown of hours and hourly rate behind the figure.

The same section added a camera to the process. Since 1 April 2025 a landlord taking a deduction has to photograph the unit after you hand it back and again after the repair, and for tenancies starting on or after 1 July 2025 there is a set of photographs from the day you moved in as well.

Washington runs on the same idea with different numbers. RCW 59.18.280 gives 30 days for a full and specific statement, requires copies of the estimates received or the invoices paid to substantiate a damage charge, and bars withholding anything for wear from ordinary use. Miss that 30-day deadline and the landlord is liable for the full deposit, with the court free to award up to twice the deposit for an intentional refusal.

Your state will have its own deadline and its own evidence rule. Look yours up before you sign, not after you drill, because it tells you whether a per-hole fee is a real risk or an opening bid.

Should you ask for a walk-through before you hand back the keys?

Yes, and in California you can insist. Civil Code 1950.5 gives a tenant the right to request an initial inspection, held no earlier than two weeks before the tenancy ends, with at least 48 hours' written notice of the date, and the stated purpose of the visit is to let you remedy what the landlord flags so it never becomes a deduction.

That is the step that converts nine holes from an unknown into a list. You walk the wall with the person who will price it, you hear the word wear or the word damage while there is still time to act, and you fill and touch up before anyone writes an itemised statement.

No such statute where you rent? Ask anyway, in writing, four weeks out. An email asking to walk the flat together and a note of what you plan to patch costs you nothing and creates a record with a date on it. Landlords who plan to charge for holes rarely put that plan in writing when asked in advance, and a written answer is worth more at the deposit stage than an argument about what was said at the door.

What I'd do

Buy the smaller set, hang it on the plainest stretch of wall, and treat the filler as part of the purchase price. On a twelve-month lease the calculation is not whether holes are allowed, it is whether five or nine of them buy you something you use daily.

Houseland rates each module in the five-piece set up to 11 lb (5 kg), which is a potted plant, a short stack of paperbacks or a row of leaning frames rather than a library. That is the load I would plan around, and it is also why the fixings can stay modest. Take an hour to spread them out, keep the hardware in a labelled bag, and the wall you hand back needs filler, sanding and a spot of paint rather than an argument. If a five-module wall is still more than you want to drill on this lease, the rest of the wall shelves range includes single ledges that put one run of fixings on the wall and nothing else.

Shop wall shelves from Houseland

-20%9-Piece Pine Hexagon Wall Shelf Setfrom $165.50$206.88-20%6-Piece Rounded Pine Box Wall Shelvesfrom $160.78$200.96-20%6-Piece Pine Cube and Ledge Wall Shelvesfrom $152.00$190.00-20%6-Piece Staggered Pine Wall Shelvesfrom $151.15$188.94-20%6-Piece Pine Honeycomb Wall Shelvesfrom $146.43$183.03-20%5-Piece Matte Black Wall Shelf Setfrom $155.59$194.49

See all wall shelves →