Mason Jar With Bamboo Lid vs Ceramic: Which Keeps Salt?

Neither material decides this. A mason jar with a bamboo lid is a stock jar you open twice a week, and a wide, shallow ceramic seasoning jar is a bench jar you open mid-cook with one hand. The figure that separates them is the mouth, not the wall: a regular-mouth canning jar opens 2.4 in (60 mm) across, and that is narrower than the hand of a 5th-percentile woman in the FAA's own measured table.

The second thing worth knowing is what each lid is doing there. A canning jar is built around a two-piece metal closure on a 70-450G thread, so screwing a wooden disc onto it switches off the part the jar is famous for. Houseland's jar was drawn the other way round, a speckled ceramic body under a bamboo lid holding about 10 fl oz (300 ml, converted from the metric figure we publish), so the wood is the design rather than a downgrade. Assume a seal on neither: we publish no seal figure for ours, and a wooden lid on a canning jar is not the closure that jar was drawn for.

Mason jar with bamboo lid vs ceramic: what is each one for?

One is a container you fill and shut; the other is a container you dip into five times a night. Every real difference below follows from that, and almost none of it follows from glass being glass.

Read that as two jobs rather than a winner and a loser. Row four decides most kitchens, because it is the difference you meet every evening; row three goes the other way.

How wide is the mouth you will be reaching into?

A regular-mouth canning jar opens 2.4 in (60 mm) across, which is narrower than almost every adult hand you could put near it. That single number does more work than any argument about the wall material. Glass packaging supplier TP Glass Bottle publishes the two finishes side by side in its mason jar specifications guide: regular mouth is 2.4 in (60 mm) inner diameter on a 70-450G thread, and wide mouth opens to about 3.4 in (86 mm) on an 86-400 thread. LOM Glassworks puts the same split in plain use terms in its jar sizing guide, rating the wide version as the one where a hand or a sponge fits easily and the narrow one as merely good.

Now put a hand against those openings. The FAA's Human Factors Design Standard measured 25 body dimensions on its Technical Operations workforce and published the percentiles in Appendix B, Table 2. Dimension 14 is hand breadth across the ends of the metacarpal bones, which is the widest part of a flat hand and therefore the part that jams on a rim.

Every one of those numbers is bigger than 2.4 in. Not one flat hand in that survey goes through a regular-mouth rim, so a wooden lid there commits you for life to whatever utensil you can post down the neck. The wide version at about 3.4 in clears the median woman, roughly matches the median man, and still stops a 3.8 in hand.

Ours is published at 4.1 in (10.5 cm) wide and 3.6 in high, with a 3.2 in (8.2 cm) spoon in the box. Note what that does not tell you: those are outside dimensions, and we publish no mouth diameter, so measure your own knuckles and hold the number against the photograph. A jar you season from is a bowl with a lid on it, not a bottle.

From the shop

Salt Cellar With Spoon, Ceramic Seasoning Jar With Bamboo Lid

Speckled ceramic body with a bamboo lid, 4.1 in (10.5 cm) wide and 3.6 in high, holding about 300 ml per jar, with a 3.2 in (8.2 cm) spoon. Sold as 1 Jar, a 2 Jar Set or a 3 Jar Set; we publish no seal or dishwasher rating, so it is a covered counter jar rather than a sealed store.

View the ceramic salt cellar — 3 set sizes & current price

Does a bamboo lid on a mason jar screw onto a real standard?

Yes, and that standard is the single strongest argument for the mason jar in this whole comparison. Its neck is a published finish code, not a shape a factory invented. TP Glass Bottle splits the code into a neck diameter and a thread style: 70-450G is a 70 mm (2.75 in) neck cut to a 450 profile, the deeper glass-specific thread Ball and Kerr standardised across North America. Packaging distributor Paramount Global lists that same 70-450G finish on glass mason jars from 8 oz to 32 oz.

The consequence is replacement. Wood moves, and a warped or split lid is one you reorder against a code from a supplier who has never heard of your jar. A moulded ceramic jar has no such catalogue: if the wooden lid on ours is damaged there is no finish code to quote and no aftermarket to shop. Price that in before you buy either one.

Two traps sit inside that standard. The codes are not interchangeable even when the neck diameter matches, so a 70-450 lid will not seat on a 70-400 jar; the pitch and depth of the cut differ. And regular and wide lids never swap. A listing saying only "fits mason jars" has told you nothing, so ask which finish and check it against the jars you already own.

Is the air trapped in a half-empty jar what stales the contents?

Mostly no: over 245 days the oxygen inside sealed packs of dried fruit fell only from 19.6% to 16.8%, and that was at 95 °F (35 °C). The pocket of air above your salt is a one-off charge, not a leak, and it is worth being clear about that before you buy a jar on the strength of the word airtight.

The figures come from a storage trial on dried apricots and raisins published in Foods and hosted at PMC6406843. Packs sealed with ordinary air started at 19.6% oxygen. After 245 days they read 16.8% at 95 °F and 19.8% at 41 °F (5 °C), so warmth drove almost all of the difference. The authors are blunter still: the films and the initial gas had no significant effect on the quality of the fruit at the end.

Dried fruit is not ground cumin and I would not carry the percentages across, but the shape of the result does carry. The air already inside behaves like a small fixed budget spent slowly, while temperature and elapsed time do the heavy work. Buy for how often the jar gets opened and how fast it empties.

Which of the two belongs on the counter, and which in the cupboard?

The jar you open five times a night lives on the counter, and the jar you open on Sunday lives behind a door. Turnover is the sorting rule, not capacity. Our own piece on whether decanting is worth it lands on six to eight jars as the honest working set for most kitchens, and everything past that is glass you bought to look at.

For the working set, shape matters more than capacity. If you season by hand at all — and there are good reasons to, which we went through in why chefs salt with their fingers — a neck you cannot get a thumb and two fingertips into is a nightly tax. It is also why Houseland lists the speckled jar as 1 Jar, a 2 Jar Set or a 3 Jar Set: the count you want is the number of things you reach for, not a volume.

For the reserve, the canning jar is the better buy and it is not close. It stacks, it is cheap, the closure is replaceable, and a narrow neck costs nothing when you visit it once a fortnight. Keep the metal lid it came with in a drawer. If the reserve is going on an open rack, our count of how many jars fit a spice rack is the check to run before you buy the jars.

How do you pick between them without guessing?

Answer five questions in this order and the choice makes itself.

1. Measure your own hand across the knuckles. Lay it flat, fingers together, and read the width at the base of the fingers. Anything over 2.4 in rules out reaching into a regular-mouth jar, and the FAA table says that is nearly everyone.
2. Ask the seller for the finish code, not the word mason. You want to hear 70-450G or 86-400. A seller who cannot say which one is selling you a lid that may not seat at all.
3. Count openings a week, not ounces. Five a night is a counter jar. Two a week is a cupboard jar. The same seasoning can honestly want one of each.
4. Check whether anything comes with it to get the contents out. A bare jar means also buying a scoop that fits the neck, and short handles go missing.
5. Decide where it physically sits before you pay. Under a wall cabinet, height is what stops the lid coming off, and a tall jar you have to lift out is a jar you stop using by about week three.

Nothing there is about glass versus clay. Four of the five are geometry.

What I'd do

Run both, and stop treating it as one decision. The bag lives in a canning jar in the cupboard, because a replaceable closure on a published thread beats everything else about it, and a narrow neck costs nothing to a jar you open on a Sunday.

The daily two or three live in something you can get a hand into, which is why a counter jar is drawn wider than it is tall. Houseland publishes 4.1 in (10.5 cm) wide against 3.6 in high with a 3.2 in (8.2 cm) spoon, sold as one, two or three jars; the rest of that shelf sits in the kitchen and home collection. We publish no seal, dishwasher or oven rating, so treat it as a covered jar you hand wash.

If you can genuinely only have one, buy the canning jar and accept the neck. It is the cheaper mistake, and it is the one you can fix with a different lid.

Shop kitchen & home from Houseland

-17%Stainless Steel Cutting Board, 304 Food-Grade, Double-Sided with Juice Groovefrom $49.99$59.99-14%Titanium Frying Pan, Uncoated, Induction Safe, with Tempered Glass Lidfrom $119.99$139.99Stainless Steel Finger Hand Protector, Knife Guardfrom $29.99-14%Kitchen Knife Sharpener, 3-Stage and 4-Stage Manual Pull-Throughfrom $29.99$34.99-40%Coconut Bowl Set of 4 with Wooden Spoons, Coconut Shell Bowls for Acai and Pokefrom $67.49$112.49-17%Coconut Wax Candle in a Coconut Shell, Cotton Wick, Hand-Poured, 4 Scentsfrom $49.99$59.99

See all kitchen & home →