Is That Mold in Your Wooden Knife Block Slots?

Probably, and your nose knows before your eyes do. Black or grey growth in wooden knife block slots is mold living on water that arrived on a blade you dried in a hurry, fed by the crumbs and starch that dropped in behind it. NSF International's 2013 household germ study swabbed 14 common kitchen items and found yeast and mold on all 14 of them, with the knife block seventh germiest by total count.

Scrubbing the slots is the easy half. The half that decides whether the growth comes back is the drying, and every published routine underestimates how long that takes for a hole a brush barely fits down. The care line on the Houseland pull-through sharpener puts the principle in seven words: tap out filings, wipe dry, keep it out of the sink.

Is the black growth in wooden knife block slots really mold?

Not always. Three different things darken a slot and only one of them is alive.

• Mold looks powdery or fuzzy, spreads sideways across the grain, and smells musty from a hand's width away. Wipe it and some lifts, some stays, and it is back within a fortnight.
• A metal mark is a hard grey-black line the exact width of the blade, left where steel has been dragged against wood for years. It transfers onto a white cloth on the first pass and never regrows.
• Food paste is brown-black, sits at the bottom of the slot rather than up the walls, and goes hard. That is flour and starch bound with the water the mold drinks.

The cheapest test costs one cotton bud. Push it to the bottom of a suspect slot and smell it: a musty cellar smell is mold, a metallic smell with a grey smear is steel, brown crumbs are dinner. Do that first, because a metal mark needs no treatment at all.

Worth knowing what the NSF study did not pin on the block. E. coli turned up on 36 percent of the items and Salmonella on 36 percent, but the items named were the meat drawer, the blender gasket, the can opener, the spatula and the pizza cutter. The block's documented problem is yeast and mold, and the study sums the cause up in four words: dark, moist environments breed germs.

How do I clean mold out of the slots without wrecking the block?

Dry work first, wet work second, and the dishwasher never.

1. Pull every knife. Wash the blades in hot soapy water, scrub where the blade meets the handle, and towel them dry straight away.
2. Turn the block over the bin and shake it hard. Then run a pipe cleaner or a skinny bottle brush down each slot while it is still dry, so crumbs come out as crumbs instead of turning to paste the moment water hits them.
3. Scrub every slot with a firm, skinny bottle brush and hot soapy water, then rinse it under the tap. America's Test Kitchen calls hot and soapy the key, because the scrubbing is what sweeps the growth out.
4. Wash the outside too, including the underside that has been sitting in whatever wet the counter.
5. Sanitize. The USDA's ratio for wooden food surfaces is 1 tablespoon of unscented liquid chlorine bleach per gallon of water: flood the surface, let it stand several minutes, rinse with clear water. For a block with visible growth, America's Test Kitchen goes far stronger, at a third of a cup of bleach per gallon of hot water and a soak of exactly 1 minute.
6. Rinse again, so no bleach is left drying inside a slot your paring knife lives in.
7. Pat every reachable face dry with a towel, then stand the block on its side or upside down.
8. Leave it. Knives go back only when a paper towel pushed down a slot comes out dry.

The dishwasher wrecks blocks three ways at once. Wood swells with the water it absorbs and cracks as it shrinks back, the same mechanism that splits cutting boards; detergent strips the finish; and the jets cannot reach down a slot anyway. A cycle that leaves wood damp for an hour feeds the thing you are trying to kill.

Bleach vs vinegar vs plain soap: what actually kills it?

The brush kills it. The liquid is a finish rather than a fix, which is how the published ratios differ by more than five times without anyone being wrong.

Two things to hold onto. The EPA's mold advice for a home does not reach for a disinfectant at all: scrub mold off hard surfaces with detergent and water, and dry completely. And a knife slot is not a hard surface. It is porous end grain, and the EPA warns that absorbent materials may have to be thrown out because mold grows into them rather than onto them.

Nothing you pour down a slot reaches growth already inside the wood, which is why the 12 hours after the clean matter more than the bottle you used. If you use the strong ratio, rinse twice. Bleach left in end grain is a smell that returns every time the wood warms up.

How long should a knife block dry before the knives go back?

Longer than the instructions suggest, and there are two published answers to pick between.

• Kitchn splits the job over two days: an air-dry overnight between the soapy stage and the bleach stage, then 12 hours or more at the end.
• America's Test Kitchen says to prop the block up and air-dry it for a few days, flipping it over periodically so the slots drain both ways.

The gap between 12 hours and a few days is the gap between the outside of the block and the inside of a slot. A slot is a dead-end pocket the width of a blade, so its water leaves only as fast as vapour can crawl out of the mouth of the hole. Stand the block upside down on two chopsticks or a cooling rack so the slot mouths are open, put a fan on it, and 2 to 3 days is realistic.

Your kitchen decides the rest. The EPA's benchmark is to clean and dry damp materials within 24 to 48 hours and to hold indoor humidity between 30 and 60 percent. A hygrometer on the counter tells you which side of that you live on: above 60 percent, take the longer estimate and the fan.

From the shop

Kitchen Tools

The care line printed on the pull-through sharpener in this collection is the rule the block needs: tap out filings, wipe dry, keep it out of the sink. It runs on no power and no water.

Browse Kitchen Tools — sizes, options & prices

When is a moldy knife block past saving?

When the growth returns within days of a clean that finished bone dry.

That test separates surface growth from growth with roots in the wood. Clean it properly once, dry it for 3 days, then look down the slots with a phone torch at the end of week one and week two. Fuzz back inside a fortnight means the mold is living below the surface where no brush reaches, and the EPA's line on porous materials applies: they may have to be thrown away because the growth has penetrated them.

Two more signals. Kitchn's last resort is sanding, which works on the outside of a block and is impossible inside a slot the thickness of a blade. And the USDA says to discard wooden boards once they are excessively worn or carry grooves that are hard to clean, a fair description of a slot scored by steel for a decade.

If you replace, replace the storage and keep the knives. A magnetic strip or an open-topped block has nowhere for water to sit. The USDA's own line is that nonporous surfaces are easier to clean than wood, which is the trade the Houseland steel board makes: listed as 304 food-grade stainless, non-porous, dishwasher safe, no oiling or soaking. That swap costs something on the blade side, and I have written about what a steel surface does to an edge rather than pretend otherwise.

Does storing knives in wood cause this, or is it the water?

The water. Wood is the reason a damp block is a nuisance rather than a hazard.

The reference experiment is old and still the clearest. In the Journal of Food Protection in 1994, Ak, Cliver and Kaspar put E. coli, Listeria and Salmonella onto wooden and plastic blocks and then tried to recover them. On plastic the bacteria came back for minutes to hours and multiplied if held overnight. Clean wood absorbed the fluid within 3 to 10 minutes, and at ordinary doses nothing could be recovered. Push it to a million cells and some survived 12 hours at high humidity, but numbers fell by at least 98 percent and often more than 99.9 percent.

Dry wood pulls water in and strands what is living in it, while wet wood does the opposite and feeds mold, which the EPA notes will grow on virtually any substance as long as moisture is present. The block is not the villain. The 4 seconds you saved not drying the blade is.

Three habits stop it coming back. Towel the blade spine-first, so the cloth never crosses the sharp side. Move the block away from the sink, the kettle and the dishwasher vent, with a finger's gap behind it. And lift it when you wipe the counter. That drying costs less time than the 2-minute weekly touch-up already does.

What I'd do

Strip it tonight, scrub it, and let the calendar make the decision.

Empty it, brush the slots dry, scrub with hot soapy water, sanitize at the USDA's 1 tablespoon per gallon, rinse, then stand it upside down on a rack with a fan for 3 days. Wash the knives while you wait and check them with the paper test before they go back, because a blade parked in a damp slot usually picks up worse than a dull edge. Then set two reminders: week one, week two.

Clear at week two, keep the block and clean it every 4 to 6 weeks, the interval America's Test Kitchen recommends. Fuzz at week two, the block goes and the knives stay, and it is worth reading how far gone a set has to be before replacing beats restoring before you spend on either. My prep gear lives out in the open on a wall strip now, with the rest of it in the kitchen tools collection, which is the Houseland sharpener's care instruction made physical: it needs no power and no water at all.

Shop kitchen tools from Houseland

-14%Kitchen Knife Sharpener, 3-Stage and 4-Stage Manual Pull-Throughfrom $29.99$34.99Stainless Steel Finger Guard, Knife Hand Protectorfrom $29.99-13%Wall Mounted Spice Rack, Steel Wire Grid Shelf with Wood Basefrom $34.99$39.99

See all kitchen tools →