Why Does Butter Go Rancid on the Counter, and How to Stop It

Green reactive glaze butter crock on an open kitchen shelf with plates and herbs

Butter goes rancid because its fat reacts with oxygen, and warmth and light speed that reaction up. The crayon or cardboard smell on a stick left out for a week is oxidised butterfat; the soapy taste is a second kind of breakdown, driven by enzymes, that unsalted butter is more open to.

So the honest answer to why does butter go rancid on the counter is that you gave it air, light and time. The fix is not the fridge, where butter sets hard and will not spread. It is salted butter only, a few days' worth at a time, kept below 70 °F (21 °C), covered, out of the light, and ideally under a water seal so no air reaches the surface at all.

Warm gray ceramic butter crock on a marble kitchen prep counter with soft evening light
PicturedWater-Seal Butter Crock with Lid, Reactive Glaze Ceramic Keeper.See 3 colours & current price

The short answer

Keep salted butter on the counter, never unsalted, in small amounts, covered, cool and dark. The University of Maine Extension's butter guidance puts salted butter at up to one to two days at room temperature below 70 °F (21 °C) in a covered dish or butter crock, and says unsalted butter belongs in the fridge and comes out only briefly to soften.

The reason the counter works at all is fat. Butter is about 80 to 82 per cent fat and 16 to 17.5 per cent water, with around 1.5 per cent salt in a salted stick, according to the Wisconsin Center for Dairy Research. Fat does not spoil the way a wet food does; it goes rancid, which is slower, and salt slows it further, so a salted stick under cover buys you days of spreadable butter rather than hours. A Houseland water-seal crock holds 4.7 fl oz (140 ml) in its lid cup, which is a little over a stick, and that is about the right amount to keep out at a time.

Why does butter go rancid on the counter?

Two reactions, and the counter feeds both. The first is oxidation: the Wisconsin Center for Dairy Research describes it as fat reacting with oxygen and producing cardboard-like off flavours. That is the crayon smell. The University of Maine page adds the three accelerants in one line: butter should be protected from heat, light and air, because each one pushes the oxygen reaction faster.

The second is hydrolytic rancidity, the breakdown of the fat by lipase enzymes, which the same dairy research page says gives soapy or, in its own words, baby-vomit flavours. Salt and cold both slow the enzymes down, which is why an unsalted stick left out goes soapy long before a salted one does.

Light is the accelerant people forget. A glass dish on a sunny windowsill gives the surface fat a dose of light all day, and the top layer goes off while the middle is still fine. The same is true of a stick left half-unwrapped in the paper: the exposed face oxidises first, so the rule is to keep the surface covered and the amount small enough to use before the surface has time to turn. Warmth then finishes the job. Butter softens to spreadable at about 60 °F (15 °C) and melts to liquid at 90 to 95 °F (32 to 35 °C), so a kitchen that hits 80 °F (27 °C) in summer is well into the range where the fat is soft, the oxygen gets in easily and the enzymes are busy.

How do you keep butter spreadable without it going off?

Keep out only what you will eat in a few days, and give it a seal against air. The water-seal crock does that better than a lidded dish because the butter sits in an inverted cup with its open face resting in water, so no air reaches the surface. Here is the routine.

  1. Use salted butter. The Maine guidance is explicit that unsalted, cultured, whipped and compound butters should stay in the fridge. Salted, at around 1.5 per cent salt, is the only everyday butter that should live on the counter.
  2. Pack a small amount. Let the butter soften, then press it firmly into the lid cup so it stays seated when the cup is inverted. The Houseland crock's cup holds 4.7 fl oz (140 ml); a hard stick dropped in will fall out into the water.
  3. Add cool water to the base, then set the lid into it. The water meets the rim and shields the butter from open air, which is the whole point of the design.
  4. Change the water every day, or every few days in a cool kitchen. Cloudy water or an off smell means empty it, wash it and start again.
  5. Keep it below 70 °F (21 °C) and out of the light. Away from the window, the hob and the top of the fridge, which runs warm. In a heatwave, put the crock in the fridge overnight and take it out at breakfast.
  6. Hand wash the ceramic with mild soap, rinse and dry before the next fill. The Houseland product page documents no dishwasher or microwave rating, and dried butter in the rim is the usual source of a sour smell.

The crock is glazed ceramic, about 4.1 in (10.5 cm) tall and 3.9 in (10 cm) across, in warm grey, blue or green, and the reactive glaze varies from piece to piece. It sits in our kitchen and home collection, and the separate piece on whether a butter crock is dishwasher safe goes into the washing question in detail.

Green reactive glaze butter crock on an open kitchen shelf
PicturedWater-Seal Butter Crock with Lid, Reactive Glaze Ceramic Keeper.See 3 colours & current price
Three ceramic butter crocks in green, blue and warm gray on an evening kitchen counter

From the shop

Water-Seal Butter Crock with Lid, Reactive Glaze Ceramic Keeper

The lid cup holds 4.7 fl oz (140 ml) of packed butter and the crock stands about 4.1 in (10.5 cm) tall in glazed ceramic with a water-seal base. Hand wash only; no dishwasher or microwave rating is documented, and the reactive glaze varies from piece to piece.

View the water-seal butter crock — 3 colours & current price

Which butters can stay out, and which cannot?

Only plain salted butter and ghee, for different reasons; everything else goes in the fridge. The table is drawn from the University of Maine Extension's butter guidance.

Butter Counter? Why What to do
Salted Yes, 1 to 2 days below 70 °F (21 °C), covered About 1.5 per cent salt and 80 per cent fat slow both kinds of rancidity Small amount in a covered dish or water-seal crock; refrigerate for longer
Unsalted No No salt to slow the enzymes; goes soapy first Fridge; out briefly to soften
Cultured No Live cultures and often lower salt Fridge
Whipped No Air whipped in means more oxygen in contact with fat Fridge
Compound (herb, garlic) No Added wet ingredients spoil faster than the fat Fridge or freezer
Clarified butter, ghee Yes, sealed Water and milk solids removed; shelf-stable in a sealed container Sealed jar, cool cupboard

Note the legal floor: US law at 21 USC 321a defines butter as containing not less than 80 per cent milk fat, so a spread below that is not butter and does not follow these rules. Spreadable tub blends with added oil are their own product with their own label instructions.

What does rancid butter smell like, and can you still cook with it?

Cardboard or crayon for oxidised butter, soap or sour milk for the enzyme kind, and no, throw it out. Rancidity is a flavour fault rather than a food-poisoning risk on its own, but the off flavour survives cooking and comes through in shortbread and sauces, and the University of Maine page notes the discolouration that goes with it. A darker yellow, translucent rind on a pale block is the visual sign.

Scraping the rind off works once on a fresh stick and not on a week-old one, because the oxidation moves inward from every exposed face. The test is the nose at fridge temperature, about 40 °F (4 °C): cold butter that still smells of anything but butter is finished. Salt hides some of it, which is why unsalted butter is the better one for judging a suspect batch.

Smell also tells you the crock is due a wash. If the water in the base smells sour, or the butter has a film at the rim, empty it, hand wash, and pack fresh. The same reasoning covers the other counter crock in a kitchen, the salt keeper, which is described in the piece on salt keeper and crock names: a ceramic lid keeps air and light off something you want at hand all day.

Butter crock dimension diagram showing height, diameter and lid cup capacity
PicturedWater-Seal Butter Crock with Lid, Reactive Glaze Ceramic Keeper.See 3 colours & current price

What I'd do

One stick of salted butter at a time, softened, packed into the crock, cool water in the base, and the crock on the shaded side of the counter well away from the hob. Change the water every morning when the kettle goes on, wash the crock each time the butter runs out, and keep the rest of the pack in the fridge, where wrapped butter lasts for several months.

In July, if the kitchen sits above 70 °F (21 °C) all day, I put the crock in the fridge overnight and out again at breakfast; ceramic 3.9 in (10 cm) across warms up in under an hour and the butter is spreadable by the time the toast is done. If the counter is already too full for a crock, the piece on fixing kitchen tools cluttering the counter is the place to make room, because the butter is one thing that genuinely earns its spot out.

Shop kitchen & home from Houseland

Stainless Steel Cutting Board, 304 Food Grade, Double Sided with Juice Groove-17%Stainless Steel Cutting Board, 304 Food Grade, Double Sided with Juice Groovefrom $49.99$59.99Titanium Frying Pan, Uncoated, Induction Safe, with Tempered Glass Lid-14%Titanium Frying Pan, Uncoated, Induction Safe, with Tempered Glass Lidfrom $119.99$139.99Stainless Steel Finger Hand Protector, Knife Guard-25%Stainless Steel Finger Hand Protector, Knife Guardfrom $29.99$39.99Kitchen Knife Sharpener, 3-Stage and 4-Stage Manual Pull-Through-14%Kitchen Knife Sharpener, 3-Stage and 4-Stage Manual Pull-Throughfrom $29.99$34.99Stainless Steel Bench Scraper and Dough Cutter-20%Stainless Steel Bench Scraper and Dough Cutterfrom $29.99$37.49Salt Cellar With Spoon, Ceramic Seasoning Jar With Bamboo Lid-50%Salt Cellar With Spoon, Ceramic Seasoning Jar With Bamboo Lidfrom $39.99$79.99

See all kitchen & home →

Questions people ask about this

How long can salted butter sit out in a butter crock?

Up to one to two days at a room temperature below 70 °F (21 °C) in a covered dish or crock, per the University of Maine Extension, and longer storage should be in the fridge. Many households push a water-seal crock further in a cool kitchen; the smell and the water clarity are your guides.

Does a water-seal crock keep butter longer than a lidded dish?

It keeps the surface off the air, which a lidded dish does not. The butter sits inverted in the lid cup with its face in cool water, so oxygen cannot reach it and light is blocked by the ceramic. The water still needs changing every day or few days, and the temperature rule does not change.

Can I keep unsalted butter in the crock?

No. The University of Maine guidance says unsalted butter should stay refrigerated and come out only briefly to soften, because it lacks the roughly 1.5 per cent salt that slows the enzymes behind soapy rancidity. Fill the crock with salted butter and keep the unsalted stick for baking from the fridge.

Why does my butter taste like crayons?

That is oxidation: butterfat reacting with oxygen, which the Wisconsin Center for Dairy Research describes as producing cardboard-like off flavours. Heat, light and air all speed it up. A stick left unwrapped on a sunny counter for a week will taste this way, and cooking does not remove it.

How much butter should I keep out at a time?

About one stick, or roughly 4 fl oz (120 ml), which is what a 4.7 fl oz (140 ml) crock cup holds when the butter is packed firmly. That is a few days of toast for a household, so it is used before the surface has time to oxidise. Keep the rest of the pack wrapped in the fridge.

Should the water in the crock be cold or room temperature?

Cool tap water, changed every day or every few days depending on how warm the kitchen runs. Cold water also chills the butter face slightly. If the water turns cloudy or smells sour, empty the crock, hand wash it with mild soap, dry it and refill before packing fresh butter.

Will butter fall out of the crock lid into the water?

Only if it was packed cold. A hard stick dropped into the cup has air behind it and drops out once inverted. Let the butter soften to spreadable, around 60 °F (15 °C), then press it firmly into the 4.7 fl oz (140 ml) cup so it grips the walls. Packed butter stays seated.

Is rancid butter dangerous to eat?

It is mainly a flavour fault: oxidised fat tastes of cardboard and enzyme breakdown tastes of soap, and both survive cooking. It is not the same as bacterial spoilage, but the off taste ruins the dish and the discolouration is a sign to discard. Throw it out rather than cooking with it.

How long does butter last in the fridge and freezer?

Wrapped butter has a shelf life of several months at refrigerator temperatures, according to the Wikipedia entry on butter, and the University of Maine guidance says refrigeration is the best choice for long-term storage. Keep the pack wrapped so the surface stays off the air and away from fridge odours.

Does ghee need to go in the fridge?

No. Clarified butter and ghee have the water and milk solids removed, and the University of Maine guidance calls them shelf-stable in a sealed container at room temperature. That is why ghee keeps for months in a cupboard while a stick of the butter it came from would not last a week.

Can I leave butter out overnight?

Salted butter, covered, in a kitchen below 70 °F (21 °C), yes; the University of Maine guidance allows one to two days. Unsalted butter should go back in the fridge. A stick left unwrapped on a plate overnight is fine to eat but has started the surface oxidation that leads to the crayon taste.

What temperature should the kitchen be to keep butter out?

Below 70 °F (21 °C), which is the ceiling the Maine Extension gives for counter storage of salted butter. Butter softens to spreadable around 60 °F (15 °C), so the usable band is narrow; above 75 °F (24 °C) the butter slumps in the cup and the fat oxidises faster.

Why does butter go off faster in summer?

Heat speeds the oxygen reaction and softens the fat so more of it is exposed. At 80 °F (27 °C) a stick is close to slumping, its surface is sweating out water, and the Maine guidance notes warmer months accelerate rancidity. Keep the crock in the fridge overnight in a heatwave.

Does light really make butter go rancid?

Yes. The Maine Extension lists light with heat and air as the three things butter must be protected from. A glass dish on a sunny sill exposes the surface fat all day and the top 1/8 in (3 mm) turns first. An opaque ceramic crock blocks all of it.

How do I tell oxidised butter from soapy butter?

Smell. Oxidised butter, fat plus oxygen, smells like cardboard or crayons; enzyme breakdown, hydrolytic rancidity, tastes soapy or like sour milk, in the Wisconsin dairy research description. Salted butter usually goes the cardboard way first; unsalted goes soapy within days out.

Can I put a whole stick in the crock without softening it?

No, it will fall out into the water. The lid cup holds 4.7 fl oz (140 ml) and the butter has to grip its walls to stay seated once inverted. Let the stick sit at room temperature until spreadable, around 60 °F (15 °C), then press it in firmly with a knife or spoon.

How much water goes in the base of the crock?

Enough that the rim of the inverted lid cup sits in it, usually about 1/2 in (13 mm) deep in a crock 3.9 in (10 cm) across. Too much water floods the butter face when the lid goes in; too little leaves an air gap at the rim, which defeats the seal. Cool tap water, changed daily.

What happens if I forget to change the crock water?

It clouds within a few days as butter particles and dust collect in it, and it can smell sour. Empty it, hand wash the base and lid with mild soap, dry, refill with cool water and repack. In a warm kitchen daily changes are the rule; in a cool one every 2 to 3 days works.

Can I use the butter crock for margarine?

Only if the tub says it can sit out. Margarine is regulated separately from butter, which by 21 USC 321a must be at least 80 per cent milk fat, and many spreads carry added water and oils that behave differently at room temperature. Follow the label, not the crock.

Is it safe to keep butter on top of the fridge?

No, it is one of the warmest spots in the kitchen. Heat from the compressor rises there and the surface often sits above 75 °F (24 °C), which softens the fat and speeds oxidation. Choose a shaded counter spot away from the hob, the window and the fridge top.

Can I freeze butter to stop it going rancid?

Wrapped butter keeps several months refrigerated, per the Wikipedia entry on butter, and freezing extends that further, though the sources opened for this piece give no freezer figure. Wrap the block airtight so the surface stays off the air, and thaw a stick in the fridge over 24 hours.

Why does fridge butter not spread?

Because butter is a firm solid below its softening point. It becomes spreadable around 60 °F (15 °C), and a fridge runs near 40 °F (4 °C), so the stick is 20 °F (11 °C) short of spreading. A stick takes an hour or so on the counter to soften, which is the wait the crock removes.

Can I microwave cold butter to soften it?

The crock cannot go in, since no microwave rating is documented, and butter on a plate melts at 90 to 95 °F (32 to 35 °C), which a microwave overshoots in seconds. Soften cold butter by cutting it into 1/2 in (13 mm) cubes on a plate for 15 minutes instead.

Does salted butter really last longer than unsalted?

Yes. Salt has been added to butter since antiquity to preserve it, per the Wikipedia entry, and the Maine Extension allows salted butter one to two days out while sending unsalted straight to the fridge. Around 1.5 per cent salt slows the enzymes behind soapy rancidity.

What is the white film on the butter in the crock?

Water that has beaded on the cut face, or sometimes a thin layer of milk solids. Wipe it off with a clean knife and check the smell. A film that smells sour, or base water that has clouded within 2 days, means the crock needs a full hand wash and fresh butter.

Can I keep cultured butter on the counter?

No. The Maine Extension puts cultured, whipped and compound butters in the fridge without exception. Cultured butter carries live cultures and often less salt, and it tastes soapy sooner than plain salted. Bring it out 30 minutes before use if you want it spreadable.

How do I clean the butter crock?

Hand wash both parts with mild soap, rinse well and dry before refilling. The listing documents no dishwasher rating. Dried butter in the rim is the usual source of a sour smell, so run a soft brush around the lip of the cup and the inside of the base, then leave both to air dry for an hour.

Why does my butter crock smell sour?

Old water or butter residue at the rim. Butter particles wash into the base and turn within a few days, especially above 70 °F (21 °C). Empty it, wash both parts with mild soap, dry, and refill with cool water; then change the water daily rather than weekly.

Can I leave the butter crock in a hot car or a camper?

No. Butter melts to a thin liquid at 90 to 95 °F (32 to 35 °C), and a closed car passes that within minutes on a sunny day, so the butter drops into the water and the fat oxidises. Keep the crock in a cooler or fridge whenever the room will run above 70 °F (21 °C).

Does the crock keep butter cold?

No, it keeps air and light off it. The water in the base is cool tap water and the ceramic is a small piece, 4.1 in (10.5 cm) tall, so the butter sits at room temperature. The point is spreadable butter that does not oxidise, not chilled butter; the temperature rule still applies.

What is the difference between a butter bell and a butter crock?

Names for the same idea: an inverted cup of butter with its face in water. Some makers use bell for the cup and crock for the base. The Houseland crock is glazed ceramic, about 3.9 in (10 cm) across, with a 4.7 fl oz (140 ml) cup, and works the same way as either.

Can I store compound herb butter in the crock?

Not on the counter. Compound butters carry garlic, herbs or citrus with their own water and spoil faster than the fat, so the Maine Extension sends them to the fridge or freezer. Slice a log into 1/2 in (13 mm) coins and freeze them; take one out per meal.

How do I know if butter has gone rancid before I taste it?

Smell it cold, at fridge temperature near 40 °F (4 °C), and look at the colour. A darker yellow, translucent rind on a paler block is oxidised fat, and any cardboard, crayon or soap note means it is done. Salted butter hides the smell a little, so sniff close to the cut face.

Can rancid butter be used for baking?

No. The off flavour survives the oven, so shortbread or a cake made with cardboard-tasting butter tastes of cardboard. The fat has not become a poisoning risk, but there is no recipe that hides it. Buy a fresh 1 lb (454 g) pack and keep it wrapped in the fridge.

How long can butter sit out for baking before it is too soft?

Around 30 to 60 minutes at a room temperature near 68 °F (20 °C) brings a stick to spreadable, about 60 °F (15 °C) in the centre. Creaming butter wants it to dent under a finger but hold its shape; a stick that has slumped past 75 °F (24 °C) will not hold air in the batter.

Is butter in a glass dish safe on the counter?

Safe for a day or two if salted, but glass lets light in and most glass dishes leave an air gap over the butter. Move it out of direct sun, and expect the surface to oxidise faster than under an opaque ceramic lid. A water seal fixes the air gap; the glass cannot fix the light.

Why does the butter in the crock taste of the fridge?

Because fat picks up odours, and a crock that spent the night in the fridge sat near onions or leftovers. Keep the crock away from strong foods, or cover the base with a plate while it chills. Wrapped butter in the fridge should stay in its paper and a closed container for the same reason.

Can I put the crock in the fridge during a heatwave?

Yes. In a kitchen above 70 °F (21 °C) all day, chill the crock overnight and bring it out at breakfast. A ceramic piece 3.9 in (10 cm) across comes back to room temperature in under an hour, so the butter is spreadable by the time the toast is done. The water seal is unaffected.

How much does a stick of butter weigh, and does the cup hold it?

A US stick is 4 oz (113 g), about 1/2 cup or 4 fl oz (120 ml) by volume. The crock cup holds 4.7 fl oz (140 ml), so one stick fits with a little room once it is softened and packed. Two sticks will not; keep the second in the fridge.

Does the reactive glaze affect the butter?

No, it is the surface look of the ceramic: rim pooling, speckling and edge tone vary from piece to piece, and the shade around the embossed BUTTER letters may differ. The cup holds 4.7 fl oz (140 ml) either way, and both parts are hand washed with mild soap and dried between fills.

Can I keep butter out in a cold pantry instead of the kitchen?

Yes, and a pantry at 55 to 65 °F (13 to 18 °C) is close to ideal: below the 70 °F (21 °C) ceiling and near the 60 °F (15 °C) point where butter spreads. Keep it dark and covered, and remember that the cool room slows rancidity but does not stop it.

Why does salted butter go off at the edges first?

Because the edges and faces are where the fat meets air and light. Oxidation works inward from every exposed surface, so a block cut on three sides has three fronts. Packing the butter into an inverted cup with its face in water leaves only one surface, and that one is sealed.

What is the 2-hour rule and does it apply to butter?

It applies to perishable foods left above 40 °F (4 °C), and butter is treated differently because of its 80 per cent fat and low water. The Maine guidance allows salted butter one to two days covered below 70 °F (21 °C). Unsalted, whipped and compound butters get no such allowance.

Can I use the crock for other things than butter?

It is sized for butter: a 4.7 fl oz (140 ml) inverted cup over a water base. Ghee, which is shelf-stable sealed, does not need the water, and soft cheeses need the fridge. Keep it for salted butter, or empty it and use the base as a small covered jar for salt.

How do I pack the butter so it does not fall into the water?

Soften it to spreadable, then push it in with the back of a spoon in 2 or 3 layers, pressing each one against the walls of the 4.7 fl oz (140 ml) cup to leave no air pockets. Level the face flush with the rim, then invert into the water. Air pockets are what let a block drop.

Does butter absorb smells from the crock water?

Only if the water has turned. Fresh cool water changed daily has no smell to give; water left a week in a warm kitchen sours and the butter face picks it up. Cloudy water is the visual cue to change it, and a hand wash of both parts every time the butter runs out resets the crock.

Can I keep European-style high-fat butter on the counter?

The same rules apply: salted, yes, for one to two days covered below 70 °F (21 °C); unsalted, no. European-style butter runs slightly higher in fat, around 82 per cent, which if anything means a little less water, but the salt content is what decides counter storage.

Why is my counter butter yellow on the outside and pale inside?

The outer layer has oxidised. Oxygen and light act on the exposed fat and darken the top 1/8 in (3 mm) or so to a translucent rind while the inside, which they have not reached, stays pale. It goes with the cardboard smell. Cut the rind away only on a fresh block; on an old one the change has gone deeper.

Will a butter crock work in a very humid kitchen?

Yes, humidity does not affect a water seal, since the face of the butter is already under water. What matters is temperature: keep the room below 70 °F (21 °C). In a humid kitchen the outside of the crock may sweat a little; wipe it and keep it off a wooden surface that marks.

How often should I wash the crock?

Every time the butter runs out, so every few days to a week with a 4.7 fl oz (140 ml) fill, plus any time the water clouds or smells. Mild soap, a rinse, and a full dry of both parts before the next pack. A rim left with old butter is what makes the next batch smell off early.

Can I put a knife in the crock and leave it there?

No. A knife left in the cup breaks the water seal when the lid is replaced and carries crumbs into the butter, which spoil faster than the fat. Use a clean knife each time and keep it beside the crock. Crumbs in the base water are also why it clouds early.

Does the crock need to be full to work?

No, but the butter must be packed firmly whatever the amount. A half fill of about 2.4 fl oz (70 ml) grips the cup walls fine if it was pressed in soft. Less butter out at a time means it is used before the surface has any chance to oxidise, which is the goal.

What is the best spot on the counter for the butter crock?

A shaded spot away from the hob, the window and the top of the fridge, on the cool side of the kitchen. The three things to keep off butter are heat, light and air; the crock handles air and light, so the spot only has to handle heat by staying below 70 °F (21 °C).

Can butter go rancid in the fridge?

Yes, slowly. Oxidation continues at 40 °F (4 °C), just far slower, which is why wrapped butter is quoted at several months rather than years. Keep it in its paper and in a closed container so the surface stays off the air and away from fridge odours, and use the oldest pack first.

Do I need to salt butter myself for the crock?

No, buy salted butter, which carries about 1.5 per cent salt already. Working salt into unsalted butter at home gives uneven coverage and does not match the protection of properly salted butter. Keep unsalted for baking, straight from the fridge, and salted for the counter.

Why does the crock lid sometimes lift or float?

Because the base has too much water or the butter cup has an air pocket. Fill the base only until the rim of the inverted cup sits about 1/2 in (13 mm) into the water, and pack the 4.7 fl oz (140 ml) cup without gaps. A lid that floats is not sealing, so fix it rather than ignore it.

Can I travel with butter in the crock?

Empty the water first. The seal only works standing still, and a crock on its side in a bag tips the water into the butter. Wrap the cup with the packed butter, carry the base dry, and refill with cool water at the other end. Keep both parts below 70 °F (21 °C) on the way.

Is a butter crock better than just buying spreadable butter?

Spreadable tubs mix butter with oil, which is why they spread from the fridge, and they are not butter under 21 USC 321a unless they hit 80 per cent milk fat. A crock keeps real salted butter spreadable for one to two days at a time without the oil, and costs nothing per week to run.

How do I stop the butter picking up the crayon smell in the first place?

Keep only a few days' worth out, salted, packed into an inverted cup with its face in cool water, in a spot below 70 °F (21 °C) and out of the light. Change the water daily. That removes air and light entirely and keeps heat in check, which are the three drivers of oxidation.