Why Japandi Rooms End Up Looking Bare, and the Fix

Japandi rooms end up looking bare because the style switches off colour and pattern and then leaves the walls blank, so the floor is the only plane that ends up decorated. Off-white, beige or soft grey walls, a pared-back palette and low furniture are part of the published description of the style, not a mistake in your version of it.

The room Japandi is quoting did not work that way. A traditional Japanese reception room built 1 wall as a recessed display alcove and set staggered shelves beside it, so the emptiness had something to be empty around. Put those 2 elements back and the bareness goes without a single extra cushion.

Why do Japandi rooms end up looking bare?

Three of the 4 channels a room uses to hold your attention are ruled out by the Japandi brief itself, and almost nobody replaces the 4th. The word is a 2016 portmanteau of Japan and Scandi, and the style is described as a pared-back colour palette with a minimalist, clutter-free approach to styling, walls in off-white, beige or soft grey, low furniture with a natural finish, and indirect lighting in warm yellow tones (Japandi). Colour is out. Pattern is out. Height is out, because low-profile furniture keeps every object near the floor.

Texture is the survivor, and texture is the one channel that cannot be seen without help. A grain, a knot or a board edge only registers when light reaches it at an angle and it throws a shadow, which is why a room can hold real oak, real linen and real stone and still photograph like an empty rental. The Houseland honeycomb set is aimed at that gap: 6 separate modules, each 3.5 in (9 cm) deep, that hang independently instead of as 1 fixed panel.

Do the arithmetic on your own wall. The ADA reach range puts the usable band for a standing adult between 15 in above the floor and 48 in (ADA Standards, 308.2.1). A low sofa back, a bed, a sideboard and the base of a floor lamp all sit inside that band. On an 8 ft ceiling that leaves roughly 48 in of wall above everything you own, and in most Japandi rooms nothing happens up there at all.

That empty upper band is the whole complaint. It is not that the room has too little furniture; it is that the furniture is all in the bottom half and the top half was never given a job.

What did the traditional Japanese room have that Japandi leaves out?

It had a designated display alcove and a run of staggered shelves, both built into the wall itself. The main reception room of a shoin-zukuri house is defined by 4 features: a recessed alcove called a tokonoma, staggered shelves, built-in desks and ornate sliding doors (shoin-zukuri). The oldest surviving building in the style, the Togu-do at Ginkaku-ji, dates from 1485, so this is not a recent styling trick.

The alcove works as a stage. A tokonoma holds a hanging scroll and an ikebana arrangement, and stepping inside it is forbidden except to change the display (tokonoma). One space, 2 objects, swapped with the season. Frank Lloyd Wright read the tokonoma as the Western fireplace, which is the closest thing most homes already have to a wall everyone in the room looks at.

That frame is what makes the emptiness legible. Ma is the Japanese word for a gap, a space or a pause, and it has been described as the silence between the notes which make the music (ma). In ikebana the space around the flowers counts as much as the flowers themselves (ikebana). Silence needs notes on either side of it.

Strip out the alcove and the shelves and you keep the gap while losing the thing the gap was a gap in. The informal sukiya version of the same room kept a decorative alcove and a shelf and used cedar, pine, hemlock, bamboo and cypress, often with rough surfaces left showing, so even the relaxed version never gave up the display wall.

Bare vs restrained: which one is your room?

Add 1 more object: a restrained room gets worse and a bare room gets better. That single test sorts the 2 conditions faster than any amount of staring, and it is worth doing before you buy anything, because the fixes point in opposite directions.

Most Japandi rooms that read as bare score on 4 of those 5 rows. The tonal row is the one people fix first and it rarely helps on its own, because 1 dark cushion on a pale sofa is still an object in the bottom band; our note on an all-beige shelf with no contrast works that half of the problem properly.

There is a second failure that looks identical from the doorway and is not the same thing: a room that is fully furnished and still feels unlived in, which we cover in the room that looks like a showroom. Bare is a distribution problem. Showroom is an ownership problem.

How do you fix a Japandi room that looks bare?

Give 1 wall the job of the alcove, put 2 or 3 levels on it, and make sure something stands off the plaster far enough to cast a shadow. Work in that order and the palette never has to change.

1. Pick 1 wall and only 1. In the shoin room a single wall carried the display and the other 3 stayed quiet. Choose the wall you face when you sit down, not the one you see from the door.
2. Work the 48 in band above the furniture. That is the strip doing nothing. Anything you hang there has to start there rather than float 6 in above the sofa back.
3. Use 2 or 3 levels, not 1 straight line. A single row repeats one horizontal that the wall already has in the skirting and the ceiling. Staggered heights are what the original rooms used, and they are the reason a shelf wall reads as composed rather than as storage.
4. Choose depth over area. A module standing 3.5 in (9 cm) off the wall on a 0.6 in (1.5 cm) board draws its own shadow line under itself all day. Flat art of the same width draws none.
5. Leave openings empty on purpose. Roughly 1 object for every 2 openings. The empty ones are the ma; fill them all and you have swapped bare for busy.
6. Change tone, not hue. Keep the off-white and the beige, and let the 1 darker thing on the wall be the wood, a stoneware pot or a single dark-spined book.

Houseland builds the honeycomb set as 6 modules rather than a matching row: 3 hexagons at 13.8, 11.8 and 9.8 in wide and 3 straight ledges of 19.7 in, which is the staggered arrangement rather than a repeated one. Every module hangs on its own keyhole hanger, so the stagger is set on the wall rather than fixed in a frame. If you want the layout arithmetic in more detail, filling a blank wall with modular shelves covers spacing, and the rest of the wall shelves range shows the other module shapes.

From the shop

6-Piece Pine Honeycomb Wall Shelves

Six modules: 3 hexagons at 13.8, 11.8 and 9.8 in wide and 3 straight ledges of 19.7 in, each one 3.5 in (9 cm) deep on a 0.6 in (1.5 cm) board. Natural pine with a clear matte lacquer, keyhole hangers, and up to 11 lb (5 kg) per piece.

View the 6-piece pine honeycomb set — dimensions & current price

Does the lighting make it look barer than it is?

Yes, and the style asks for precisely the lighting that hides the only channel it left itself. Japandi calls for indirect lighting in warm yellow tones, which means light arriving at a surface from many directions at once after bouncing off a ceiling.

Lambert's cosine law, published in Photometria in 1760, sets out why that flattens everything: the light landing on a surface is proportional to the cosine of the angle between the incoming ray and the surface normal (Lambert's cosine law). Light a flat wall square on and the cosine is 1 across the whole plane, so every part of it receives the same amount and nothing has an edge.

Now tilt the source. At 60 degrees off the normal the flat wall receives half of what it got head on, because the cosine of 60 degrees is 0.5, while any small face turned toward the light keeps a higher cosine and stays bright. That difference between the flat and the raised is exactly what a grain, a knot or a board edge needs in order to be visible.

In practice: put 1 source within about 12 in of the wall plane and aim it along the wall rather than at it. A sconce mounted on the display wall does this by accident, which is why the japandi and wabi-sabi sconce notes and this article end up describing the same wall. A ceiling fitting in the middle of the room does the opposite.

What I'd do

Treat 1 wall as the alcove and leave the other 3 alone. On that wall I would work the 48 in band above the furniture and hang the 3 hexagons as a stagger, the 13.8 in one highest, the 11.8 in and 9.8 in stepping down and across, with the 19.7 in ledges below them carrying a single horizontal.

Then I would under-fill it. Two or three objects across 6 modules, with the smallest openings left empty, and 1 of those objects clearly darker than the wall. Houseland rates each piece to hold up to 11 lb (5 kg) and asks that weight be spread across modules rather than loaded onto 1, which suits this kind of styling anyway: a pot, a small stack of books, a bowl.

Last, move a light. One wall-mounted source near the display wall, or a table lamp pushed close to it, will do more for the texture than another object will. If after all that the wall still reads thin, the answer is a second level rather than a wider one.

Shop wall shelves from Houseland

-20%9-Piece Pine Hexagon Wall Shelf Setfrom $165.50$206.88-20%6-Piece Rounded Pine Box Wall Shelvesfrom $160.78$200.96-20%6-Piece Pine Cube and Ledge Wall Shelvesfrom $152.00$190.00-20%6-Piece Staggered Pine Wall Shelvesfrom $151.15$188.94-20%5-Piece Matte Black Wall Shelf Setfrom $155.59$194.49-20%9-Piece Matte Black Hexagon Wall Shelvesfrom $174.58$218.23

See all wall shelves →