How to choose wall art for home without returning it

How to choose wall art for home is four decisions taken in a fixed order: wall size, light direction, the dominant material already in the room, then style. Measure the wall first and buy something that covers 60 to 75% of it, hung so the centre of the piece sits 57 to 60 in (145 to 152 cm) off the floor. Style goes last because style is the only one of the four you can judge from a phone screen, and the other three are the ones that send the parcel back.

Why does picking the style first send it back?

Style is the only one of the four decisions the room does not get a vote on. The wall has a width, a light source and materials already in it, and those three settle whether a piece looks deliberate or looks stuck on at the last minute. The order matters because three of the four decisions are made with a tape measure and one is made with your eyes, and the tape measure ones cannot be argued with afterwards. You can love a finish in a listing photo and still hang it where it covers a third of the width instead of 60 to 75%, and liking it will not close the gaps either side. The Houseland pebble totem is 19.7 in (50 cm) tall and 13.8 in (35 cm) wide, and those two numbers tell you more about whether it belongs on your wall than anything on the label. Read the return window on your order confirmation before you drill anything, and put that date in your phone. A piece still on the wall two weeks after the date has passed is a piece you own.

How to choose wall art for home: which decision comes first?

Wall size, and it is not a close call. Run these four in order and the last decision gets easy, because by the time you reach style, three of the four filters have already run.

1. Measure the wall, not the room. Take the width of the plaster you are actually filling, gap to gap, then multiply it by 0.6 and by 0.75. Those two answers are the width range the art has to land in, so a 30 in (76 cm) gap beside a door wants 18 to 23 in (46 to 58 cm) of art across it.
2. Find the light before you find the art. Stand at the wall twice, once at midday and once after dark, and note which side the light arrives from each time. A 2,700 K bulb keeps cream and sand warm, while 4,000 K reads cool and flattens the same finish towards grey.
3. Name the dominant material. Walk the room and count how many separate places each material turns up: oak, brass, black metal, linen, ceramic, stone. The one that appears in two or more places is the material the art answers to, and if nothing repeats, use whatever covers the largest surface.
4. Choose the style last. By then you are picking from pieces that are already the right width, that hold up under your light and that echo a material you own, which is usually a list of two or three rather than a whole category page.

Vertical art vs horizontal art: which shape fits the wall?

Vertical wins on anything narrower than about 23 in (58 cm), horizontal wins above furniture, and the width you measured in step one settles it.

The sofa row is the one people get wrong, because the instinct is to measure the wall when the number that matters is the sofa, and there is more on that in the piece on how high to hang wall art above a sofa. Vertical also works where the wall is tall and thin, which describes most of what is left once a door, a radiator and a light switch have taken their share. Two or three smaller pieces hung as one block count as a single width for the 60 to 75% rule, which is the entire idea behind building a gallery wall.

What does light direction do to a textured piece?

Side light is what makes a textured piece read as three-dimensional, and flat light from the front kills it. The largest of the five pebbles carries fine carved striations, and they only show when light crosses them at an angle and throws a soft shadow down the wall. There is no LED in this one, no cable and no battery compartment, so all of that depth comes from the room's own light and there is no wattage to plan around. A wall directly opposite a window gets light straight on for most of the day, and straight-on light flattens the striations out. Put the piece on a wall at 90 degrees to the window and the same finish picks up a shadow line that moves across the afternoon. After dark it comes down to the bulb: 2,700 K holds the cream and sand, 4,000 K turns the cream grey and the rust-brown disc muddy. That gap between how a colour looks in a photograph and how it looks on your own wall is worth reading about in the piece on why a colour matches in photos and clashes at home before you blame the piece.

Which material in the room should the art answer to?

The one that already appears in two or more places. If oak is in the floor, the coffee table and the shelf, oak is the dominant material and everything else in the room is a guest. Matching wall art to furniture is really matching it to the finish on the furniture rather than to its colour: an oak sideboard and a cream pebble share a matte surface even though nothing about them is the same shade. A matte, hand-textured stone effect answers oak, linen and unglazed ceramic, because none of those bounce light back at you. It fights high-gloss lacquer and polished chrome for the same reason. The palette here runs warm cream and sand through the upper pebbles, a rust-brown disc in the middle and a grey stone tone at the base, four tones that sit against sage or plain white without asking the rest of the room to move. If you are choosing paint at the same time, pick the art first, and there is a longer argument for that in the piece on whether to choose the wall art or the paint colour first. Paint comes in thousands of shades and can be changed in an afternoon; this piece comes in one colourway.

From the shop

Wabi Sabi Wall Art, Stacked Pebble Totem in a Stone-Effect Finish

Houseland's stacked pebble totem is 19.7 in (50 cm) tall and 13.8 in (35 cm) wide, hangs vertically and needs no power, cable or battery. Matte stone-effect finish in cream, sand, rust-brown and grey, wall mounted and ready to hang.

See the wabi sabi wall art

Which walls should this finish stay off?

Any wall that gets standing steam or direct water. The stone-effect finish is porous, so one shower line marks it and a damp cloth does the same. A well-ventilated cloakroom away from the shower is fine, and an enclosed wet room is not. The same rule puts it off the wall directly behind a hob. The 19.7 in (50 cm) body is laser-cut MDF under that finish, which is what keeps it light enough for a standard plasterboard fixing and also why it does not want water. Care is one soft dry cloth and nothing else: no solvents, no damp cloth, no oiling, dusted the way you would dust a picture frame.

How do you hang a vertical piece at the right height?

Centre the piece 57 to 60 in (145 to 152 cm) off the floor and work outwards from there.

1. Mark the centre line. Measure 57 in (145 cm) up from the floor in a room where people sit down, 60 in (152 cm) in a hallway where they are standing, and pencil a mark.
2. Work out the top and bottom edges. On a 19.7 in (50 cm) tall piece, a 57 in (145 cm) centre puts the top edge at about 67 in (170 cm) and the bottom at about 47 in (119 cm). Cut a sheet of paper to 19.7 by 13.8 in (50 by 35 cm) and tape it up before you commit to anything.
3. Above a sofa, ignore the floor. Set the bottom edge 6 to 8 in (15 to 20 cm) above the back of the sofa, which usually puts the centre a little above 57 in (145 cm) anyway.
4. Check what is behind the plaster, then relax about it. Studs sit at 16 in (41 cm) centres in most homes, but Houseland includes mounting hardware that suits standard plasterboard and masonry, and the piece is light enough that finding a stud is not part of the job.
5. Fit the fixing and hang it. Mark the position, fit the supplied fixing, hang the piece on it, then walk back and look from where you actually sit rather than from 12 in (30 cm) away with a spirit level in your hand.
6. Leave it up until the return date passes. This is the step that gets skipped at 11pm when the parcel arrived that afternoon, and it is the step that decides whether you keep it.

What would I buy first?

The narrow wall, every time, because narrow walls are the ones that stay blank for years. A 13.8 in (35 cm) wide vertical piece solves the strip beside a door, the gap above a console and the dead end of a hallway. The stacked pebble totem is $139.99 and ships with a set of faux stems and the mounting hardware, which puts it in the bracket covered by the round-up of the highest quality wall art under $200. The holder at the top takes one slim stem, dried or faux, and it is not a water-holding vase, so treat a fresh cut flower as short-term styling. If your wall measures wider than 23 in (58 cm), this is the wrong shape for it and something horizontal from the wall art collection is the better buy. Measure the wall tonight, before you look at a single photograph, and write down two numbers: 60% of the width and 75% of it. Anything outside that range is not a matter of taste, it is the wrong size, and no finish rescues it.

Shop wall art from Houseland

-17%LED Wall Art with Shelf and Bud Vase, Backlit Stone Textured Panel for Above Sofafrom $499.99$599.99-17%LED Wall Art with Shelf and Bud Vase, 59 in Backlit Stone Textured Panelfrom $499.99$599.99-13%LED Wall Art with Shelf and Bud Vase, Fluted Sandstone Backlit Panelfrom $349.99$399.99-15%LED Wall Art with Shelf and Bud Vase, Oval Backlit Panel for Living Roomfrom $549.99$649.99-13%Backlit Plaster Wall Art, Japandi LED Ring with Walnut Shelf and Bud Vasefrom $349.99$399.99-15%Wall Mounted Vase with LED Backlight, Textured Capsule Panel and Shelffrom $274.99$324.99

See all wall art →